12 Best Amazon Prime Big Deal Days Squishmallows Deals (October 2026 Sale)

If you are building a Squishmallows shelf or buying plush for a birthday list, the picks worth watching in this year’s Amazon Prime Big Deal Days sale start with Anya the Caticorn, a 16-inch Squishmallows plush that pairs a 4.9 rating across 9218 reviews with a size that works as both a hug and a pillow. For variety rather than a single character, the official 8-inch Mystery 3-Pack covers three characters per box, and the 20-inch Maui Yellow Pineapple is the one to watch if you want something a child can actually nap on. Prime Big Deal Days runs October 6-7, 2026, and most offers need a Prime membership, where a free trial counts.

What follows is a list of Squishmallows listings chosen for design, size range, construction and how owners actually rate them, not a list of confirmed markdowns. Offers shift through the event, so treat the button on each card as the only place the current price lives.

Our Top 3 Picks for Best Amazon Prime Big Deal Days Squishmallows Deals (October 2026)

Best Amazon Prime Big Deal Days Squishmallows Deals Compared

How We Chose

We compared every listing on design and character appeal, size and packaging options, material and construction details, and the ratings and written reviews owners leave on Amazon. Listing information was checked in October 2026, and the picks that follow are the ones that hold up when you look past the character name.

1. Anya the Caticorn: Editor’s Choice

Nothing else in this roundup pairs a 4.9 rating with a review count as deep as Anya’s, and the softness is the reason it comes up first in owner comments. Reviewers describe the fabric as the squishiest they own, and several mention machine washing it on a warm cycle and finding it even softer afterwards with colours that held.

At 16 inches this is the size that suits almost any gift. It is big enough to hug properly, still light enough for an older child to move around, and the listed dimensions of 16 by 15 by 14 inches mean it sits more like a cushion than a flat pillow. Several owners use it as a reading pillow, and the machine-washing reports make it a safer bet for a household with kids than something that only looks good on a shelf.

The same listing carries Watermelon and Octopus variants, which is worth checking if you are buying more than one. The mint, yellow and teal palette is the more distinctive of the three, but the other two sit closer to the classic Squishmallows look.

Compared with the 20-inch Maui Yellow Pineapple, Anya is the tidier choice. Maui is the better nap pillow; Anya is the one that fits on a bed without taking a pillow’s worth of space. If you want a very small plush for a party bag instead, the Squishville Fruit Squad Minis are a different format entirely, and better suited to that job.

Good to know: the manufacturer guidance is three years and up, and the single recurring criticism in reviews is cosmetic, a shade that looks slightly lighter in person than on screen.

2. Mystery 3-Pack 8 inch: Best Value

This is the most reviewed listing in the roundup, with 10292 reviews, and that volume is the point. Three official plush per box means the fastest route to a shelf that already looks like a collection rather than a single lonely character staring back at you.

Owners are clear about the trade-off. The characters are a mix of established favourites, new styles and Amazon exclusives, which keeps the box interesting, but you choose the box rather than the character. If a specific design is non-negotiable for a birthday, this is the wrong format; if you are buying for a child who has not picked a favourite yet, the surprise is usually a feature.

At 8 inches and 0.7 kg for the whole pack, these are also the easiest to handle and the easiest to wash. The listing states the fabric is washable, and reviewers confirm putting them through a machine cycle causes no lasting damage. That practicality is why a lot of owners treat this box as the entry purchase and add named characters later.

Collectors often call the 8-inch format the sweet spot for everyday use, and this box is the quickest way into that size. Compare it with the Squish-a-longs 25 Pack, which gives you far more figures at 1 inch each but is hard plastic rather than squishy plush. Pick the mystery box if the squeeze matters; pick the 25-pack if the count does.

Skip it if you are buying for someone who has named a specific licensed character. For that, the Pokemon Pikachu and the Bluey HugMees are the safer bets.

3. Maui Yellow Pineapple 20 inch: Best for Body Pillowing

A 20-inch Squishmallow is roughly the size of a body pillow, and that is exactly how owners use this one. Reviews describe sleeping with it, napping on it during long car journeys, and giving it to children and teens who wanted something they could physically lie on.

The filling is what earns the praise. Reviewers squeeze it repeatedly and report that it springs back rather than staying dented, and the stitching is consistently called clean at this size, which is harder to achieve than it looks. The green top and the bright yellow body photograph well, and it holds a spot at the centre of a collection without looking oversized next to a wall.

Size options listed for this character include 12 inch, 5 inch, 16 inch and 20 inch, so a household that likes the design does not have to commit to the jumbo version. That flexibility is worth checking on the listing, because the character is far more collectible across sizes than most.

Set against the 24-inch Pierogi Banana Monkey, the difference is one of bulk rather than function. Maui weighs 5 pounds and moves more easily; Pierogi is the largest in the range and noticeably harder to reposition. Against the 16-inch Anya, Maui wins for sleeping and loses on everything to do with sharing a bed.

Good to know: it is a soft pillow, not a structured one. Anyone hoping for back support should look elsewhere.

4. Squishville Fruit Squad Minis: Best for Backpack Charms

At 2.05 by 1.42 by 2.28 inches and 3.52 ounces each, these are small enough to clip to a backpack loop or drop into a prize machine without a second thought. Six fruit characters arrive in one pack, with the lineup covering peach, pineapple, watermelon and more.

It is the lowest-rated listing here at 4.4, and the reason is almost always the same: expectation. Buyers who pictured palm-sized plush are disappointed, while buyers who wanted something small for party prizes, goodie bags or display next to full-size characters are delighted. The soft marshmallow texture survives the scale surprisingly well, which is not something you can say for every mini format.

Sizing is the practical thing to check before ordering. The outer box is compact enough to fit in a stocking, and the pieces can be split between several children, which makes this a genuinely useful multi-recipient buy rather than a single gift that has to be won outright.

Compare it with the Squish-a-longs 25 Pack, which trades squishiness for count. The Squishville minies are the softer of the two and the far more giftable; the 25-pack is the better starter set for a collector. Other squads are listed too, including Rainbow Dream Squad and Fantasy Squad, so a collector can collect by squad rather than randomly.

Good to know: a small number of reviews mention sewing imperfections or an outer box that arrived crushed, so check the packaging on arrival.

5. Junie Yellow Banana 14 inch: Best Gift for Young Kids

Fourteen inches is the size that gets described most often in reviews as bigger than expected while still light enough for a small child to pick up and move. Junie scores 4.9 across 3634 reviews, and the words that come up most are soft, well stitched and giftable.

Owners note that it holds its shape after being squeezed and can be fluffed back into position, which matters more for a plush that lives on a child’s bed than for one that stays on a shelf. Reviews also describe it landing well as a gag gift, which is useful when a birthday list has not been filled in and you need something that makes people laugh.

The character comes in Grey Possum, Tie-dye Sea Slug and Yellow Banana variants. The banana is the bright, high-contrast option that photographs best and reads clearly at a distance, which matters when a child is choosing between characters on a shelf.

Where this sits against the Pokemon Pikachu is simple: both are 14-inch official plush with clean embroidery, and the difference is licence rather than construction. Junie is an original Squishmallows character and tends to be the more approachable gift; Pikachu carries an existing franchise that some children already know.

The listed dimensions of 7.87 by 11 by 14 inches make this a plausible birthday gift for a five-year-old to a ten-year-old without being a nap pillow. Choose the 20-inch Anjali or Maui if sleeping with it is the plan.

6. Pikachu 14 inch Pokemon: Best for Licensed Characters

Licensed characters carry more collector weight than original designs, and the Pokemon line is the clearest example in this roundup. A 4.9 average across 2410 reviews comes from people who already know the franchise and wanted a specific character in Squishmallows form rather than a generic plush.

Reviewers repeatedly single out the embroidered details on the face and ears, plus accurate character colours, as the reasons the plush holds up next to a shelf of original Squishmallows. At 2.3 pounds and 14 inches it is described as a comfortable hugging size and even shows up as a travel or car-seat pillow, which is a fairly demanding thing for a squishy to do and one it manages.

Snorlax, Gengar, Teddiursa and Pikachu are all listed on the same style, so a household collecting the line can keep the sizes and formats consistent. That is a real advantage if the goal is a matched row on a shelf rather than one plush that stands apart from the rest.

Against the Bluey HugMees, the trade is licence against function. Bluey is a HugMees design with extended arms built for wrapping around a child, while Pikachu is a standard 14-inch character. Against the 24-inch Pierogi, the Pokemon line is the compact option in a big family of characters.

Good to know: the most repeated request in reviews is a larger size within the Pokemon line, which is worth checking against the current listing.

7. Bluey HugMees 10 inch: Budget Pick

The Bluey HugMees is the cheapest way into an officially licensed character in this list, and at 6 ounces it is also the easiest plush here for a small child to carry around. The HugMees format exists for one reason: the arms extend so short hands can wrap all the way around.

With 2959 reviews at 4.8, the design is well liked and the colouring is consistently described as recognisable, which is the main test for a licensed plush. Owners also note that several Heeler family characters get bought together, so the format supports a small collection rather than a one-off.

The limitation is size. At 10 inches this is a cuddle companion, not a pillow, and reviewers say so plainly. If the gift is for a child who wants something to sleep on, the extra spend on the 14-inch Junie or the 20-inch Anjali is money well spent.

Bluey, Bingo, Chili, Muffin and Bandit are all listed, so the specific design is not always the one in the main image. That is the single most important thing to verify on this listing before ordering, and it is a five-second check that avoids most of the one-star feedback this product receives.

8. Anjali Purple Elephant 20 inch: Best for Tie-Dye Colours

Anjali is the 20-inch option for someone who likes the tie-dye side of the range. The purple body, tie-dye ears and flower detail are the design features reviewers mention first, and at 4.9 across 1329 reviews the colour work is doing the heavy lifting.

Size impressions are consistent: owners say it is larger than they expected, and several describe a three-year-old lying on top of it. At 2.5 kg the filling is genuinely fluffy and reviewers note it resists matting, which is a fair complaint about cheaper plush at this scale. The listed dimensions of 13 by 20 by 16 inches give a fair idea of the footprint before it lands on the sofa.

There is one manufacturing theme worth reading before ordering. A small number of buyers report a plush arriving with a hole in the face and loose fibre, and returned it. It is not a majority report at a 4.9 average, but it is specific enough that checking the face and seams on arrival is worthwhile.

Compared with Maui Yellow Pineapple, both are 20 inches and both are rated above 4.8. Maui wins on the sheer size of the review base and a fruit design that is easier to place in an existing collection; Anjali wins on colour, which is the more distinctive addition to a shelf.

9. Pierogi Banana Monkey 24 inch: Best for Max Size

Twenty-four inches is the ceiling of the range, and Pierogi is the plush that reaches it. Owners use it as a full body pillow, and at 4.8 across 823 reviews the enthusiasm comes mostly from the sheer scale of the thing arriving in the room.

The banana-monkey design is singled out as more distinctive than the run of animal Squishmallows, and it comes with a named character and backstory like the rest of the line. The listed dimensions of 19 by 24 by 22 inches make it the biggest object in this roundup by a clear margin, which is the appeal for anyone who wants a gift that visibly changes a room.

The trade-off is moving it. At 4.35 kg, this is the heaviest item in the list, and reviews describe it as awkward for younger children to lift and reposition. That is a real consideration in a shared bedroom or a small flat where floor space is already contested.

Two more sizes are listed for the character, including a tie-dye mushroom and a brown shar pei dog, so the same design language is available in smaller formats. If the jumbo version is too much, the 20-inch Anjali is the same scale one step down, and the 16-inch Anya is the sensible shelf size.

At 823 reviews this is the thinnest review base here, so owner feedback covers the design and softness well but says less about long-term durability than the better-reviewed picks.

10. Slimygloop Mix Ems Slime: Best for Party Favours

This is the odd one out in the roundup, and it earns its place for a specific reason. If your event involves a table covered in newspaper, ten ready-made slimes are a better fit than another plush, and the three included Squishmallows charms tie it back to the collection.

What arrives is five scented cloud slimes and five scented glitter slimes at 1 ounce each, eight mix-in packets covering sequins, sprinkles, foam balls and glitter, 50 faceted jewel beads, and the three rubber charms. Scents run from kiwi and strawberry to pineapple, blue raspberry and cake, which is the detail that comes up most in reviews about parties.

Convenience is the main theme in owner feedback. Nothing needs measuring or mixing, and the containers reseal, so a slime can survive a car journey or a week in a cupboard between birthdays. That practicality is why this scores 4.8 across 1168 reviews despite being a completely different product category from the plush around it.

The honest caveat is mess. Reviews describe it as genuinely messy, and the pre-made consistency is thinner and faster-running than slime mixed from scratch, which is the trade you make for skipping the mixing. Plan for surface protection and close supervision, and it works well.

Compared with the Squish-a-longs Party Pack: the playset is a keepsake that travels, while the slime is an activity that gets used once and is done. Different jobs, both aimed at a party.

11. Squish-a-longs 25 Pack: Best for Starting a Collection

Twenty-five characters at one inch each is the densest way to start a Squishmallows collection, and the numbered collector guide is what makes it work. You can see at a glance what you are still missing instead of buying blind.

The single most important thing to know before ordering is that these are hard plastic mini figures, not plush. Several buyers flag the mismatch with the Squishmallows name explicitly, and it is the reason this pack lands at 4.8 rather than closer to the 4.9 the plush listings reach. Buy them for collecting, trading, wearing and displaying, not for squeezing.

Beyond the figures themselves, the set includes five accessories and a ring so the pieces can be worn or hung, and there is a chance of a shimmery chase character in the pack. The wider line runs to more than 140 Mini-Squish, which is what turns a single box into something you keep opening.

Against the Squishville Fruit Squad Minis, both are small-format packs and the difference is material. Six soft 2-inch fruit plush against 25 rigid 1-inch figures is a real fork: softness and giftability on one side, count and collection structure on the other.

Guidance is for ages six and up because of the small parts, and only one ring is included for the whole pack, so the figures need to share it.

12. Squish-a-longs Party Pack: Best for Travel Play

The Party Pack is a backpack that opens into a scene, and that single design decision is what separates it from every other listing here. With 645 reviews at 4.8, owners keep coming back to the same point: the format travels, and the bag holds the pieces when the play is over.

Nine furnishings fill the scene, including bean bag chairs, a sleep pod and a pool floatie, and reviewers repeatedly note that the count of furniture is generous compared with the three characters included. Adjustable straps and a front storage pocket are called genuinely useful rather than decorative, which is a compliment to a toy that has to be carried by a child.

As with the 25-pack, these Mini-Squish are rigid plastic. The listing is recommended for children six and up, and the honest framing is that this is a playset with collectible figures attached, not a squishy plush set. Buy it for the scene and the bag, and the figures become the bonus.

Where the 25-pack is a flat box for goodie bags and advent calendars, this is a durable, reusable item that can be handed to a child with younger siblings. For a long car journey or a restaurant wait, the backpack format is the difference between a toy that survives the outing and one that ends up lost in a seat gap.

At 0.57 kg it is light enough for a child to carry themselves, and more Mini-Squish are available across the wider line if the characters become the collecting interest.

How to Choose Squishmallows During Prime Big Deal Days

Squishmallows listings look similar until you notice that two of them are not the same product at all. Some are polyester plush, some are rigid plastic mini figures, and one is slime. Sorting those three categories first makes every other decision easier.

Character and Design

Decide between a named character you already love and an original design before you look at anything else. Licensed characters such as Pokemon Pikachu and Bluey carry recognisable designs that collectors value, while original Squishmallows characters are cheaper to expand into because the whole range is available in one visual language.

For seasonal shopping, colour matters more than character. The tie-dye and pastel finishes on Anjali and the Squishville Fruit Squad read as birthday and spring gifts, while the plain fruit designs work year-round. A collector building a shelf usually wants consistent sizes and a deliberate palette rather than whatever looks best in one box.

Size and Pack Format

The size jump is bigger than most first-time buyers expect. An 8-inch Squishmallow is a hand-sized cuddle, a 14-inch is a lap pillow, a 16-inch is a full pillow, a 20-inch works as a body pillow, and 24 inches is the largest in the range. Anything below 2 inches is a charm or prize, not a plush you hug.

Pack format changes the maths of a collection. The Mystery 3-Pack gives three 8-inch characters at once, the Squish-a-longs 25 Pack gives 25 figures at one inch, and the Squishville Fruit Squad gives six 2-inch fruit plush. Bulk packs suit goodie bags and starter collections; single characters suit someone with a specific design in mind.

Material and Construction

Plush listings in this roundup are polyester outer and inner material, and the recurring owner comment is about stitching rather than fill. Junie and Pikachu are both praised for clean seams, while a small number of reports on the 20-inch Anjali describe a face hole and loose fibre on arrival. That is a reason to inspect the plush the moment it arrives, not a reason to skip a size.

Then check what the product actually is. The Squish-a-longs packs are hard plastic despite the Squishmallows name, and the Slimygloop set is plastic containers of slime rather than a plush at all. Buying the wrong category is the single most common complaint in the reviews across this roundup.

Listing Details and Value

Check the variant list before you add anything to a cart. The Bluey HugMees listing covers Bluey, Bingo, Chili, Muffin and Bandit, and the Pokemon listing covers Pikachu, Snorlax, Gengar and Teddiursa, so the image in the main listing is not always the item you will receive. Anya is offered in Watermelon, Caticorn Mermaid and Octopus for the same reason.

Also read the count rather than the headline. One plush or three is the difference between a gift and a small haul, and a mystery box never guarantees a specific design. Owner reviews are the best source on whether a listing delivers what the photos imply, which is how the 2-inch Squishville minies picked up their 4.4.

How to Shop Squishmallows Deals During the Sale

Confirm three things before you commit: the character or model variant, the size, and whether the box contains one piece or several. Then look at the seller and shipper line, since a third-party seller and a fulfilled-by-Amazon offer are not the same proposition when something needs to be returned. Condition matters more than usual during an event, since a pre-owned plush can look identical in photos. Most offers during Prime Big Deal Days need a Prime membership, and pricing changes through the two days.

• Match the size to the recipient: 8 inches for a hand, 14 for a lap, 20 for sleeping
• Confirm the variant name on the listing matches the character you want
• Count the pieces in the box before you assume how many gifts you have
• Decide between squishy polyester plush and rigid plastic mini figures first
• Check who sells and fulfils the order before buying during a busy event
• Open the plush on arrival and check the seams and stuffing

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict: Amazon Prime Big Deal Days Squishmallows Deals

Watch Anya the Caticorn first if you are buying one Squishmallow and want the strongest all-round listing, a 4.9 rating and a 16-inch size that handles both hugging and napping. For the budget-friendly route, the Bluey HugMees 10 inch costs the least to enter and is the easiest size for a small child to carry, while the Mystery 3-Pack 8 inch is the better value if variety matters more than picking a name.

The rest of the list covers the specific jobs. Buy Maui Yellow Pineapple 20 inch or Pierogi Banana Monkey 24 inch when the point is a body pillow. Buy Junie Yellow Banana 14 inch or Pokemon Pikachu 14 inch for a birthday gift at a size that works for a child on a lap. Buy the Squishville Fruit Squad Minis for backpacks and goodie bags, the Squish-a-longs 25 Pack to start a collection, the Party Pack for travel, and the Slimygloop set when the event is about slime rather than plush.

Check each live listing during the sale before you commit, since the variant you want may not be the one shown and offers change through the two days.